Blog

Are Native Ads Worth Overhyped? Here's Why and Why Not

What Performance Marketers Still Don’t Get About Native Traffic

Let’s have an honest moment. Native traffic? It’s that misunderstood cousin in the marketing family. Everyone nods when it’s mentioned, maybe even throws a few bucks its way, but no one’s really inviting it to the VIP table. And that’s wild—because native, when done right, is pure gold.

The problem? A lot of performance marketers still don’t get how it actually works. They treat it like another version of Facebook ads or a Google Display campaign. And in doing that, they’re missing out on serious scale potential. Let’s dive into why native gets such a bad rap, what marketers keep doing wrong, and how to start thinking about it the right way.

Native Isn’t Just Another Ad Channel—It’s a Different Game Entirely

Here’s the thing. Native advertising isn’t just another placement or a traffic source. It’s not a lookalike of social or search. It’s its own unique ecosystem. Ads appear as content suggestions—on top publisher sites—thanks to platforms like Taboola, Outbrain, Revcontent, and MGID. It feels organic, because it’s meant to. It’s designed to blend into the content users are already consuming.

And that’s the first thing most marketers don’t account for. Native isn’t trying to interrupt your audience with a big “BUY NOW” button. It’s trying to slide into their reading experience like a helpful nudge. So when you treat it like any other performance platform, you instantly miss the mark.

Curiosity Clicks Aren’t Intent Clicks

One of the biggest disconnects? Marketers expect native traffic to convert like search traffic. Spoiler: it won’t. Not at first, anyway.

See, people clicking native ads aren’t actively searching for your product. They’re not problem-aware the way a Google user is. They’re in chill mode—reading a news article, browsing a “10 Surprising Health Tips” list, or looking for something to pass the time while their coffee brews. When your ad shows up, it piques their interest, not because they want to buy something, but because they’re curious.

That curiosity is a powerful lever. But if you meet it with a hard sell or a generic product page? They’re out. Native traffic isn’t broken—it’s just driven by a different type of user intent. And when you fail to align your messaging with that, of course it feels like it’s “not working.”

The Real Killer: Weak Creatives and One-Dimensional Testing

Another biggie—marketers simply don’t test enough on native. Most run a couple of headlines, toss in a stock image, and call it a day. Then they wonder why the CTR is trash or the CPCs are climbing.

Native requires aggressive creative testing. You can’t rely on targeting tricks like you can on Meta. Your ad is your targeting. That means your headline and image combo need to do all the work to pull people in.

Best practice? Launch with 10–15 headline variations. At least 10–12 image options. Throw in multiple advertorial variations too. Yes, it’s more work. But native rewards volume and iteration. Think of it like running 20 little A/B tests at once to find the one gem that skyrockets your campaign.

Stop Sending Native Clicks to a Product Page—Please

Let’s pause here. Because this one? This one hurts to see.

Marketers are still sending native traffic straight to product pages. Straight. To. Checkout. It’s like someone getting halfway through an article on gut health, clicking your ad, and suddenly being dropped on a sterile Shopify page asking them to buy a supplement for ₹7,400 (that’s around $89). It’s jarring.

Here’s what native needs: a bridge.

That bridge is called an advertorial—a content-style pre-lander that warms up the user, tells a story, provides context, and gradually introduces your offer. It eases the transition from curiosity to interest to purchase. It’s not about tricking users; it’s about respecting the journey they’re on.

If you’re skipping this step, you’re not just missing conversions—you’re burning your ad spend.

Understand the Psychology or You’ll Miss the Point Entirely

The mindset of a native user is different. They didn’t wake up today thinking, “I need this product.” They saw a hook that sparked something—emotion, surprise, intrigue. That’s your entry point.

The goal is to ride that emotion and guide them toward a decision without forcing it. Your ad should start a conversation. Your pre-lander should build a story. And your offer should feel like the natural conclusion to the problem they just realized they have.

Native thrives when you lead with emotion and follow with logic—not the other way around.

Some Offers Just Aren’t Built for Native (And That’s Okay)

Let’s be honest—native doesn’t work for every offer. It’s not great for high-ticket B2B SaaS tools or complex services with long sales cycles. If your product requires a 30-minute explainer video to even make sense, native might not be your channel.

But if you’re selling something that solves a relatable, everyday problem? Native loves you.

Think health, wellness, gadgets, personal finance, survival gear, weight loss, dating, parenting, skincare. These are broad, emotion-driven markets. And native traffic eats them up—especially when they’re packaged in stories, listicles, or curiosity-based content.

Native Takes Time—But the Scale Is Worth It

Here’s what separates native winners from losers: patience.

Native doesn’t give you instant gratification. You might not get a 2x ROAS in the first 48 hours. But if you understand that the early spend is for data—not profit—you’ll be miles ahead.

The first ₹83,000 (about $1,000) in spend? Consider it your insight budget. Use it to identify top-performing creatives, gather scroll-depth metrics, monitor click behavior, and refine your funnel. Most people give up too early—right before it would’ve started working.

Stick with it, tweak fast, and iterate based on what the data’s telling you. That’s where the scale comes in.

Use Retargeting to Close the Loop

Don’t just rely on native to do all the heavy lifting. Once you’ve introduced someone to your offer via native, retarget them on platforms like Meta, YouTube, or Google Display.

This isn’t cheating—it’s smart marketing. You’re taking warm traffic and moving them toward conversion through multiple touchpoints. Your native ad did its job by generating interest. Now your retargeting campaign can deliver a stronger CTA, a time-sensitive offer, or even just a reminder.

That combo? It's a conversion engine.

Final Thoughts: Respect the Channel, Reap the Rewards

Native traffic isn’t dead. It’s not low-quality. And it’s definitely not a “cheap clicks” graveyard.

It’s just misunderstood.

If you approach it with the same strategies you use on social or search, you’ll lose. But if you respect the platform—if you lean into curiosity, tell better stories, build smart funnels, and test like crazy—native can become one of your most profitable traffic sources.

So the next time someone tells you native doesn’t work, just smile. Because while they’re chasing the latest algorithm change on Meta, you’ll be quietly scaling your campaign behind a click-worthy headline and a killer story.

At Intexm, we don’t just run native traffic—we understand it. We’ve spent months mastering what makes users click, what keeps them engaged, and what actually converts curiosity into action.

From crafting thumb-stopping headlines to building high-performing pre-landers that feel like content (not ads), we treat native as the unique, powerful ecosystem it is—not just another checkbox in the media plan. While others see native as a gamble, we see it as one of the smartest ways to scale when you know how to play the game right. And trust us—we’ve learned to play it well.

...